Contractual Liability 和 Your Work 是两个不同的 exclusion。
🧠 RIBO考试记忆法
看到:
“Contract says you will pay…”
不要马上选:
❌ CGL赔 也不要马上选: ❌ CGL一定不赔
先问:
是不是 Contractual Liability exclusion?
然后再问:
是不是属于 Insured Contract?
最后再问:
有没有其他 exclusion,例如 Your Work?
🔥 给你一道陷阱题
ABC Renovation signs a contract with a customer stating that ABC will repair its own defective workmanship at no cost to the customer. The roof is installed incorrectly and later leaks. The customer asks ABC to replace the defective roof.
Which is MOST accurate?
A. CGL will pay because ABC has a contractual obligation to repair the roof.
B. CGL will pay because the loss occurred after the contract was signed.
C. The cost to repair ABC’s defective work is generally excluded under the Your Work exclusion.
D. The loss is covered under Impaired Property.
你先选答案。
C
✅ 完全正确:C
这题你已经抓住了 RIBO 最重要的判断逻辑。
为什么是 C?
题目说:
ABC 自己安装的屋顶有问题 → 要把自己的 defective work 修好。
所以核心不是“有没有合同”,而是:
损坏/需要修复的是 ABC 自己的 work。
因此首先想到:
🚫 Your Work Exclusion
CGL不是用来保证承包商:
“把自己的工程做好”
所以 修复自己有缺陷的屋顶的费用,通常由 ABC 自己承担。
A 为什么错?
“因为合同规定 ABC 必须修,所以 CGL赔。”
❌ 签了合同 ≠ CGL自动赔。
合同责任本身还要看:
Contractual Liability exclusion
是否属于 Insured Contract
是否还有其他 exclusion
而且这里即使合同本身符合某些 insured contract 条件,Your Work exclusion 仍然可能排除修复自己工作的费用。
D 为什么错?
题目没有说:
东西没有损坏,只是不能使用。
恰恰是:
屋顶本身安装错误,需要更换。
所以不是 Impaired Property。
🔥 你现在已经掌握这条逻辑链
Contract → 不代表一定赔
↓
先看是不是 Insured Contract
↓
再看有没有其他 exclusion
↓
如果是:
Repair your own defective work
→ 🚫 Your Work
如果是:
Defective work → damages customer’s other property
A contractor agrees by contract to indemnify a property owner for certain claims arising from the contractor’s operations. This is an example of:
A. Subrogation B. Contractual liability C. Contribution D. Contributory negligence
2.
A contractor promises to complete a renovation by June 1 but does not finish until July 15. The homeowner suffers financial loss because of the delay.
This is MOST directly an example of:
A. Breach of contract B. Subrogation C. Occupiers’ liability D. Vicarious liability
3. ⭐
Which statement is MOST accurate?
A. All contractual liability is automatically excluded under every CGL policy. B. Any claim involving a contract is automatically covered by CGL. C. CGL policies generally contain a contractual liability exclusion, but exceptions may apply for certain Insured Contracts. D. CGL policies exist primarily to guarantee contractual performance.
4.
A restaurant signs a lease containing an agreement under which the restaurant assumes certain liability of the landlord. The restaurant’s CGL policy may respond depending on whether:
A. The restaurant owns the building. B. The agreement qualifies as an Insured Contract and other policy conditions are met. C. The landlord has no insurance. D. The restaurant has made a profit.
5. ⭐⭐
Which BEST describes an indemnity agreement?
A. An agreement to share insurance premiums. B. An agreement under which one party agrees to compensate another for specified losses or liabilities. C. An agreement to cancel an insurance policy. D. An agreement transferring ownership of property.
6.
A contractor negligently damages a third party’s property while performing work. The contractor also has a contract requiring it to indemnify the property owner for certain claims.
Which statement is MOST accurate?
A. Only contractual liability can exist. B. Only negligence can exist. C. Both negligence and contractual obligations may be relevant. D. Neither can exist because the contractor has insurance.
7. 🔥
A business agrees in a contract to guarantee that its product will perform perfectly for five years. The product fails to perform as promised, but there is no bodily injury or property damage.
Which statement is MOST accurate?
A. CGL automatically guarantees the contractual promise. B. This is primarily a contractual performance issue, not automatically a CGL claim. C. It is automatically covered because a contract exists. D. It is automatically covered under the Products-Completed Operations section.
8. 🔥🔥
A contractor’s employee accidentally damages a customer’s building while performing renovation work. The customer sues the contractor for property damage. Separately, the contractor has a contractual agreement to indemnify the building owner for certain claims.
Which statement is MOST accurate?
A. The existence of the contract automatically excludes all coverage. B. The claim may involve both negligence/property damage and contractual liability issues; the policy wording must be examined. C. The contractor cannot be liable because the employee caused the damage. D. The claim is automatically a breach-of-contract claim.
A contractor’s employee accidentally damages a customer’s building while performing renovation work. The customer sues the contractor for property damage. The contractor also has a contract requiring it to indemnify the building owner for certain claims.
Homeowner automatically vicariously liable for plumber’s negligence.
九、但是!Independent Contractor 不是绝对免责
又来了一个考试喜欢的词:
Automatically
千万小心。
即使是 Independent Contractor:
Principal 自己可能因为自己的 Negligence 而承担责任。
例如:
你明知道这个承包商:
没有资格 没有安全措施 明显不适合做这个工作
你仍然把危险工作交给他。
那么可能出现:
Direct Negligence
这和:
Vicarious Liability
是两个不同概念。
十、这两个一定要分清
Vicarious Liability
别人做错 → 我因为法律关系承担责任
例如:
Employee negligence → Employer
Direct Negligence
我自己做错 → 我自己承担责任
例如:
Employer hired an obviously incompetent worker despite knowing the risk.
这可能是 Employer 自己的 negligence。
🧠 一张表记住
情况
可能的责任
Employee negligent while doing job
Employer 可能 Vicariously Liable
Employee 自己 negligent
Employee 也可能负责
Employee commuting home
通常不自动属于 course of employment
Small personal detour
要看具体事实
Major personal frolic
Employer 可能不承担 Vicarious Liability
Independent Contractor negligent
不自动让 Principal Vicariously Liable
Principal 自己选择/监督存在过失
可能 Direct Negligence
🔥 最重要的考试口诀
看到:
Employee + Accident
不要马上:
Employer liable ❌
先问:
Employee acting in the course of employment?
如果:
YES → Vicarious Liability 可能成立
如果:
NO → 通常不能仅因为雇佣关系就让 Employer 承担 Vicarious Liability
🎯 现在来 8 道 RIBO 陷阱题
1.
A restaurant employee is delivering food as part of his regular duties when he negligently hits a pedestrian.
Who may potentially be liable?
A. Only the employee B. Only the restaurant C. Both the employee and the restaurant D. Neither
2.
Which factor is MOST important when determining whether an employer may be vicariously liable for an employee’s conduct?
A. Whether the employee has personal insurance B. Whether the employee was acting in the course of employment C. Whether the employee owns a vehicle D. Whether the employee has worked for the employer for more than one year
3. ⭐
An employee finishes work and drives directly home in his own vehicle. During the commute, he negligently hits another vehicle.
Which statement is MOST accurate?
A. The employer is automatically vicariously liable because the driver is an employee. B. The employer is always liable for anything an employee does outside work. C. The employer will not normally be vicariously liable merely because the person is an employee. D. The employee cannot be liable because he was driving after work.
4. ⭐⭐
A delivery driver is instructed to deliver a package. On the way, he makes a five-minute detour to buy coffee and then continues the delivery. During the detour, he negligently causes an accident.
Which statement is MOST accurate?
A. Any personal detour automatically ends the employer’s potential liability. B. The employer may still potentially be vicariously liable depending on the circumstances. C. The employee cannot be liable because he was on a personal detour. D. Only the coffee shop can be liable.
5. 🔥
A delivery driver abandons his assigned route and drives 30 kilometres in the opposite direction to visit a friend for personal reasons. During this trip, he causes an accident.
This conduct is MOST likely described as:
A. Course of employment B. Detour C. Frolic of his own D. Direct negligence by the employer
6.
Which statement about an employee’s negligence is MOST accurate?
A. Once an employer is vicariously liable, the employee can never be liable. B. An employee can never be personally sued for negligence committed during work. C. The employee may remain personally liable, while the employer may also be vicariously liable. D. Only the employer’s insurer can be liable.
7. ⭐⭐⭐
A homeowner hires an independent contractor to repair the roof. The contractor negligently damages a neighbour’s property.
Which statement is MOST accurate?
A. The homeowner is automatically vicariously liable because the contractor was hired by the homeowner. B. The homeowner is never liable under any circumstances. C. The homeowner is not automatically vicariously liable merely because the person is an independent contractor. D. The neighbour has no possible claim.
8. 🔥
A company knowingly hires an unqualified contractor to perform dangerous electrical work despite knowing that the contractor lacks the necessary expertise. The contractor causes a serious fire.
Which concept may apply to the company’s own conduct?
A. Vicarious liability only B. Direct negligence C. Contributory negligence by the contractor only D. Subrogation
A customer slips on water in a supermarket and breaks her arm. Which statement is MOST accurate?
A. The supermarket is automatically liable because the customer was injured. B. The supermarket is liable whenever a customer falls on its premises. C. The supermarket’s liability depends on whether it failed to take reasonable care to keep the customer reasonably safe. D. The supermarket is never liable for accidents caused by water.
2. ⭐
A store employee spills water on the floor. The employee immediately places a warning sign and begins cleaning the spill. A customer ignores the sign, walks directly through the wet area and falls.
Which statement is MOST accurate?
A. The store is automatically liable because the customer was injured. B. The warning sign guarantees that the store cannot be liable. C. The store’s reasonable steps to address the hazard may be relevant in determining whether there was a breach. D. Customers assume all risks when entering a store.
3. ⭐⭐
A small spill occurs in a supermarket. Thirty seconds later, before any employee could reasonably discover the spill, a customer slips and falls.
Which issue is MOST important in determining whether the supermarket breached its duty?
A. Whether the customer purchased anything. B. Whether the supermarket had a reasonable opportunity to discover and address the hazard. C. Whether the customer had health insurance. D. Whether the customer signed a waiver when entering the store.
4. ⭐⭐⭐
Which person could potentially be considered an occupier?
A. Only the registered owner of the property. B. Only the person who holds the mortgage. C. A person or organization with sufficient control or responsibility over the premises. D. Only a government authority.
5. 🔥
A restaurant knows that grease frequently accumulates near its entrance. Despite several previous incidents, the restaurant does not change its cleaning procedures. A customer slips on grease and suffers a serious injury.
Which combination is MOST relevant?
A. Duty and Breach B. Breach and Causation C. Damage and Deductible D. Both A and B
6. ⭐⭐⭐
A shopping mall has a reasonable inspection system. An employee checks the floor every 15 minutes. A customer slips on a drink that was spilled only one minute earlier.
Which statement is MOST accurate?
A. The mall is automatically liable because the customer was injured. B. The mall may be able to demonstrate that it took reasonable precautions. C. The mall has no Duty of Care toward customers. D. The employee is automatically personally liable.
7. ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Which statement about a warning sign is MOST accurate?
A. A warning sign always eliminates an occupier’s liability. B. A warning sign is irrelevant if someone is injured. C. A warning sign may be one factor in determining whether the occupier took reasonable care. D. A warning sign transfers all legal responsibility to the customer.
8. 🔥
A homeowner invites a friend into the home. The homeowner knows that a staircase is dangerously defective but does not warn the guest. The guest uses the staircase normally and is injured.
Which is the BEST analysis?
A. The homeowner has no Duty because the guest entered voluntarily. B. The homeowner may have a Duty and may have breached it by failing to take reasonable precautions. C. The guest automatically assumes all risks. D. The homeowner is liable only if the guest paid to enter the home.
这时候,s.3 的普通 Duty of Care 不适用这些被自愿承担的风险。Occupier 剩下的核心义务是:
不能故意制造危险来伤害对方
不能对对方的存在采取 reckless disregard(鲁莽漠视)
这是考试最重要的区别。
2. Trespasser 什么时候进入这个特殊规则?
这里是重点。
Ontario OLA s.4(3) 对某些特定场所规定:
如果进入者未经许可进入,并且场所属于 s.4(4) 列出的类型,就会被视为:
willingly assumed all risks
这些场所包括:
农业用地
vacant / undeveloped land
forested / wilderness premises
未开放营业的 golf course
utility rights-of-way / corridors
unopened road allowances
合理标示为 private road 的私人道路
合理标示的 recreational trails
portage routes
这是 Ontario 法律明确规定的。
3. 举个非常典型的例子
情况 A:普通超市
John 未经允许进入一个正常营业的超市后方区域。
他在那里受伤。
不能简单套用:
“Trespasser → willingly assumed all risks。”
因为你首先要看:
这个场所是不是 s.4(4) 所列的特定 premises?
普通商业超市并不属于这个特殊清单。
因此不能仅仅因为他是 Trespasser,就自动把所有风险都推给他。
4. 情况 B:森林 / 农场
假设:
一个私人森林 ↓ 明确禁止进入 ↓ John 仍然进入 ↓ 在树林里被一个自然地形危险绊倒
如果符合 s.4(3) 和 s.4(4) 的条件:
John 会被视为:
willingly assumed all risks
因此 Occupier 不再承担普通 s.3 的 Duty of Care 来保证他“reasonably safe”。
5. 但是!这里就是最重要的陷阱 🔥
即使 John 是这种情况下的 Trespasser:
Occupier 也不是可以“随便伤害他”。
s.4(1) 仍然保留两项义务:
① No deliberate harm
不能:
故意制造危险来伤害 Trespasser
例如:
明知道有人晚上会翻墙进来,故意在入口设置一个致命陷阱。
❌ 不能说:
“他是 Trespasser,所以我什么都能做。”
② No reckless disregard
不能:
明知对方在那里,却对他的存在采取 reckless disregard。
也就是说:
不能故意/鲁莽地无视他的存在而让他遭受危险。
这正是 Ontario 法律对 Occupier 留下的最低限度保护。
6. RIBO 最值得背的一张表
情况
Occupier 的基本规则
普通 Customer / Visitor
Reasonable Care
普通进入者受到危险
s.3 Duty
某些 Trespasser + s.4 特定 premises
Willingly assumed all risks
Criminal activity
Willingly assumed all risks
Recreational activity + 符合 s.4 条件
Willingly assumed all risks
Occupier 故意制造危险伤害对方
❌ 不能
Occupier 对对方存在采取 reckless disregard
❌ 不能
7. 特别注意:Trespasser ≠ Automatically s.4
这是你考试一定要注意的。
不要看到:
Trespasser
就马上选:
“Willingly assumed all risks.”
你还必须看:
Where did the trespass happen?
如果是:
农田 / 森林 / wilderness / 某些 recreational trails 等
才可能进入 s.4(3) 的特殊规则。
8. Criminal Trespass 又有一点不同
如果这个人进入场所的目的本身就是:
committing a criminal act
s.4(2)规定,他会被视为:
willingly assumed all risks
而 Occupier 同样只剩下 s.4(1) 的最低义务:
No deliberate harm + No reckless disregard。
所以考试如果写:
“A person enters the premises intending to commit a criminal act.”
看到这个条件,就要马上想到:
s.4(2) → willingly assumed all risks
🧠 最终口诀
你可以把 Ontario Trespasser 记成:
Trespasser ≠ Automatically No Liability
但是:
s.4 applies → Assumed All Risks
然后再问:
Did the Occupier deliberately create danger?
或者:
Did the Occupier act with reckless disregard?
如果答案是 Yes:
👉 Occupier 仍可能承担责任。
🎯 给你一道真正的 RIBO 陷阱题
A person enters a privately owned forested property without permission. While trespassing, the person is injured by a natural hazard on the property. The occupier did not know the person was there and did not deliberately create the hazard.
Which statement is MOST accurate?
A. The occupier automatically owes the same reasonable-care duty as to a customer.
B. The trespasser is deemed to have willingly assumed the risks, subject to the limited duty not to deliberately create harm or act with reckless disregard.
C. The occupier is automatically liable because every person entering property is owed a full duty of care.
D. The occupier has absolutely no duty under any circumstances.
这道题的关键就是 “forested property + without permission + natural hazard + no knowledge + no deliberate harm”。
Contributory Negligence → apportionment of responsibility
🎯 现在来做 8 道题
1.
A supermarket fails to clean up a spill. A customer slips and is injured. The customer was looking at her phone and failed to notice a clearly visible warning sign.
Which concept may apply to the customer’s conduct?
A. Subrogation B. Contribution C. Contributory Negligence D. Insurable Interest
2.
A customer is found to be 25% responsible for her own injury, while the supermarket is 75% responsible. The customer’s assessed loss is $100,000.
Ignoring other issues, approximately how much would the customer recover?
A. $25,000 B. $50,000 C. $75,000 D. $100,000
3. ⭐
Which statement is MOST accurate?
A. Contributory negligence means the defendant has no liability. B. Contributory negligence may reduce the plaintiff’s recovery. C. Contributory negligence means the plaintiff committed a criminal offence. D. Contributory negligence automatically makes both parties 50% responsible.
4.
A restaurant fails to clean a dangerous spill. A customer sees the spill but deliberately walks through it while running.
Which statement is MOST accurate?
A. Only the restaurant can be negligent. B. Only the customer can be negligent. C. The restaurant may have breached its duty, while the customer’s conduct may constitute contributory negligence. D. Neither party can be negligent.
5. ⭐⭐
Which question is MOST relevant when determining whether a plaintiff was contributorily negligent?
A. Did the plaintiff have insurance? B. Did the plaintiff take reasonable care for their own safety? C. Did the plaintiff own the property? D. Did the defendant have a deductible?
6. 🔥
A store has a wet-floor sign clearly visible. The customer sees the sign but decides to ignore it. The store had recently cleaned the area and was taking reasonable steps to deal with the hazard.
The customer falls and is injured.
Which is the BEST analysis?
A. The store is automatically 100% liable because the customer was injured. B. The customer is automatically 100% liable because there was a warning sign. C. The customer’s conduct may support contributory negligence, and the store’s reasonable precautions may also be relevant to whether there was a breach. D. There can be no liability because a warning sign always eliminates liability.
7. ⭐⭐⭐
Which statement BEST distinguishes contributory negligence from assumption of risk?
A. They are exactly the same legal concept. B. Contributory negligence concerns the plaintiff’s failure to take reasonable care; assumption of risk involves knowingly and voluntarily accepting a risk. C. Assumption of risk applies only to property damage. D. Contributory negligence applies only to criminal cases.
8. 🔥🔥
A supermarket’s negligence causes $200,000 in losses. The injured customer is found to be 30% responsible for the loss.
Which statement is MOST accurate?
A. The supermarket owes nothing because the customer was partly responsible. B. The customer automatically receives $200,000. C. The customer’s recovery may be reduced according to the customer’s share of responsibility. D. The supermarket and customer must each pay exactly $100,000.